Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
 
Old 11-23-2007, 01:18 PM   #1
4 Rivet Member
 
Currently Looking...
Two Harbors , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 311
TV Emergency Handling - Lane Switch and Slalom

Hi All...In my continuing effort to learn about TV combinations and performance...I purchased RVLifestlye Issue Vol 35, No 7...which I beleive was a spring 2007 issue.

I ordered the older issue to read the test results performed by Andy Thomson od CanAM RV.
'
Andy took a number of tow vehicles to a test track and set up a high speed lane change and a slalom...as simulation for the most typical freeway speed emergency manuvers.

He used a 34' As and Hensley hitch as his test tow combination...and tested that set-up with a Jaguar, a Chrysler 300, a Frod Freestar, a Buick Rensevous, A VW Jetta, a Surburban.and two crew cab pick-up trucks...a GMC 1500HD and a GMC 2500HD Diesel.

Conclusion (in summary)...the low center of gravity vehicles w/low profile tires performed the best in theser emergency handling tests...the Suburban had the poorest test results...with the 3/4 ton diesel the second worst.

The Jaguar had the best test results with all of the other vehicles "handling" the emergency manuvers better than the "favorite" 3/4 ton diesel and the Suburban. BTW...the Suburban was tested with stock tires AND with a lower profile tire...and did perform better w/the lower profile tires.

The test did not include a stopping test...just the emergency performace handling. Maybe Andy will do a similar stopping test...although I seem to remeber an earlier test that showed the heavier pick-ups stoipping more slowly that the lighter tow vehicles...since the trailer brakes actually help stop the TV...not vice versa.

Before all the rants...please read the article rather than just reciting the same..."only bigger is better" towing answer.

Also, be sure to note in the article that the TVs were modified as CanAm always recommends...ie low profile tires, perhaps stiffer shocks if appropriate.

The logic of lower center of gravity, lower profile tires and firm suspension seems extremely strong for the freeway emergency handling Andy tested...how is it you can think a 2500HD with a very high center of gravity and very high ration tires could perform sudden manuvers well...in a freeway speed emergency?

The more I read...the more I think further study of this issue is appropriate. I do know that many are not open to this discussion...just want their big pick-em-up trucks!

For those who are curious...I suggest you try to get a copy of the article and read carefully. I am aware that CanAM as been discussed and dismissed by many...not sure that is the most open minded approach...back to the Turkey left-overs!

Tom R in Two Harbors, Minnesota
__________________

__________________
TomR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 02:06 PM   #2
Rivet Master
 
Fyrzowt's Avatar
 
2000 25' Safari
West of Fort Worth , Texas
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 6,697
Images: 8
Interesting. Did you have any trouble finding the magazine? Where did you find it?
Thanks, Dave
__________________

__________________
Fyrzowt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 02:30 PM   #3
4 Rivet Member
 
Currently Looking...
Two Harbors , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 311
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fyrzowt
Interesting. Did you have any trouble finding the magazine? Where did you find it?
Thanks, Dave
Hi Dave...I ordered it online. My wife's mother is from Canada and I just subscribed to the magazine...in addition to ordering the "old" issue. I keep telling her we can visit Canada more often IF we had an AS.

I think I learned about the article (and the magazine) when it was mentioned by a poster in my earlier thread reagarding CanAM.

Tom R
__________________
TomR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 02:31 PM   #4
Site Team
 
azflycaster's Avatar
 
1975 25' Tradewind
Dewey , Arizona
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 12,127
Images: 62
Blog Entries: 1
Here it is:
Canada's Leading RV Lifestyle Magazine
You need to buy the magazine to read the whole article, but they also have several on line articles which talk about towing and tow vehicles. Very interesting reading.
__________________

Richard

Wally Byam Airstream Club 7513
azflycaster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 02:49 PM   #5
_
 
. , .
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,812
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomR
...set up a high speed lane change and a slalom...as simulation for the most typical freeway speed emergency manuvers.

The logic of lower center of gravity, lower profile tires and firm suspension seems extremely strong for the freeway emergency handling Andy tested...how is it you can think a 2500HD with a very high center of gravity and very high ration tires could perform sudden manuvers well...in a freeway speed emergency?
#1. herein lies the basic and critical flaw in this entire exercise.

the premise that 'lane changes' are the preferred freeway emergency maneuver...

when slowing down or stopping, WITHOUT changing lanes is almost ALWAYS the best action.

'lane changing' is in fact an extremely dangerous action, and the actual cause of many avoidable highway collisions....

and sadly OVER used by modern (metro loop) inexperienced drivers.

yes there are occasional situations where lane changing might be the preferred action.

but NOT many.

when towing out on the 'high seas' of the interstate, veteran long haul drivers give a wider birth, as they should.

yes i realize 'trucker drafting' happens but that again is a different issue.

approaching metro areas the behaviors change because of the local drivers and their behaviors...

towing into/around metro areas, we need to pick the ideal lane, be aware of those around us, use lights and signals and NOT be part of the race...

#2. why the surprise that a low center car with low profile tires and tuned suspension handle better?

of course they do.

but towing isn't about sports car handling. towing IS about behaving like the better professional overtheroad truckers do...

-anticipate, leave space, know YOUR stopping distance, and give a wide birth to the nuts in cars darting in-n-out of traffic...

in other words safe towing is about reducing the potential of high speed events.

it is NOT about closed course high speed lane changing, leave that to the sports cars...

towing is not about following so close that the only option is swerving into another lane...

one of the many advantages to a truck is the ability to see 'over and beyond' the small cars in front of us.

rv towing is a completely different driver skill set.

yes big trucks and suvs are over used for daily drivers and have inherent issues (mpg, roll over, head/neck injuries, braking)

but again towing, and especially a BIG trailer is about other issues.

using the jag as an example...

-limited cargo, limited vision, limited off road, in the grass, rv park, bookdocking potential.

i would NOT choose to tow a 34 with a jag, even if the jag was FREE...

give most a/s have marginally adequate cargo space, the truck IS for hauling crap!

3. low profile tires....

again an absolute need for performance driving, but for towing?

http://www.airforums.com/forums/270722-post12.html

so the demand from towing tires and the characteristics of good towing tires are very different from performance tires.

high mileage, good punture resistance, extra load capacity, grip in all conditions, resistance to curbs and pot holes, and so on...

yes there are now 20 inch truck tires with improved load capacity but again...

i would NOT choose to tow the 34 with 20s, even if the 20s were FREE!

4. suspension

the attributes of a great towing suspension are not the same as a great handling performance suspension...

(porsche cayenne asside)

load carrying capacity, adjustablilty, durability, steering that ISN'T to tight, and comfort are needed for towing.

while tight steering, good high speed on center feel, properly balanced under/over steer, good road feedback, and so on define performance steering.

5. braking

the few published comparisions demonstrate that a big truck (f-250) towing a trailer with disc brakes...

stops in less distance than the truck alone.

BUT the tv still needs to be able to stop/control the trailer, should the trailer brakes fail or malfunction.
____________________________________

i love driving fast on closed courses and tracks.

i love what great sports cars can do.

i'm sure the towing exercise was fun, i'd love to have been driving (not using MY trailer)...

but folks looking for sports car handling and attributes while towing...

need to understand that is NOT what safe towing is about...

don't get lost in the performance specs and keep the BIG picture in view.

again learning to behave like the BIG/GROWN UP truck drivers do is the responsibility that comes with towing.

cheers
2air'
__________________
all of the true things that i am about to tell you are shameless lies. l.b.j.

we are here on earth to fart around. don't let anybody tell you any different. k.v.
2airishuman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 03:08 PM   #6
4 Rivet Member
 
Currently Looking...
Two Harbors , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 311
2air...I am disappointed .

I agree with just about everything you say...but that does not negate the value of an emergency avoidance manuver test. Yes, tow like a trucker (or an adult), yes, try to stop instead of change lanes if possible...but the rest of your narrative is not up to your normally highly analytical, intellectually curious posts.

Seems to me...

1) Low center of gravity...are you saying that a higher center of gravity is better for towing?

2) Low profile tires...YOU may not want 20" but IF they have adequate weight ratings...why would a HIGHER profile tire (and the extra "sway" that may accopmpany)...be BETTER for towing?

3) Slalom and Lane change tests...no one said that this was a sports car test...why would it be BETTER to tow with a vehicle that performs POORLY when taxed in an extreme, emergency type situation? Notice I said nothing about it being the ONLY factor in testing a tow vehicle for emergency response.

4) Have you read the article...I trust you have.

In my opinion, this article is a valuable, controlled test of the emergency handling reactions of a sample of tow vehicle combinations...with a Hensley and a 34' AS...and the most often recommended heavy tow vehicles (Suburban and 3/4 ton CC Diesel) did poorly...at a MINIMUM it is food for thought and further discussion

I wonder if Andy at CanAm has done similar braking tests? Seems like I saw a reference to such?

Come on now...you Duramax/Allison owners...let's have some "on target" discussion instead of diversion and anecdote...Tom R
__________________
TomR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 03:19 PM   #7
_
 
. , .
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,812
i've already tried to explain why low profile tires are a negative....

and when it comes to suvs or trucks low profile tires CONTRIBUTE to roll over accidents and loss of control events.

no i didn't suggest a higher center of gravity is better.

an adequate tv is better.

IF center of gravity is your concern (it isn't mine) LOWER the truck...

slalom and lane change exercises demonstate characteristics of the hensley...

but are a misdirection of the safe and proper towing set up issue.

that's the point.

cheers
2air'
__________________
all of the true things that i am about to tell you are shameless lies. l.b.j.

we are here on earth to fart around. don't let anybody tell you any different. k.v.
2airishuman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 03:23 PM   #8
Rivet Master<br><img src="/ugala/forums/images/5rivet.gif">
 
CanoeStream's Avatar

 
2006 25' Safari FB SE
St. Cloud , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 13,279
Images: 19
Blog Entries: 3
The frequently linked video with a Cayenne swerving towing an Airstream vs. SOB shows slight differences in the driver input IMO. Where's the validity? So much of this is subjective. It is said the CG is lower if you have your water tanks full -- variables abound and I'm not sure this can be quantified. Yes, a truck or SUV has a high CG. If I'm so out of control that I have to worry about that, I fear both TV & trailer are going to take a major hit -- I'll wish only that I can walk away.

When the trailer tries to take over and do the steering I think I'd rather be driving a tow vehicle that weighs 3 tons rather than 2. Sorry to pull him in to this but 85MH325 said earlier today, ""You can move a train with a sewing machine motor, if it's geared properly." Stopping the train once it's moving is another matter altogether."
__________________
Bob

5 meter Langford Nahanni

CanoeStream is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 05:41 PM   #9
_
 
. , .
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,812
the editors at grassroots motorsports did a 'comparison' that made the cover back in march 2003...

they pitted a honda odyssey minivan against a porsche 356 and a jaguar (series 2) xke...

on an autocross course!

the minivan lap times were equal (within 0.01 sec) to the porsche...

and they both beat the jag!

it was fun to read, and demonstrated that...

-the modern minivan handles well,
-a japanese fwd box can out race 30-40 year old english and german 'sports cars'..
-old porsches are not very fast...
-old jags look cool in the paddock...
and
-car guys get to do fun/crazy stuff....

but not many minivans entered autocross events as a result.

what's any of this have to do with towing?

the odyssey minivan was normally used to tow the editors real autocross car

so maybe it's a little bit of a surprise that a modern jag can win a handling comparison...

against a diesel truck or a bourbon...

but i'm a little disappointed the 300m couldn't take the jag...

and i'd gladly take the bathtub porsche if given the opportunity.

cheers
2air'
__________________
all of the true things that i am about to tell you are shameless lies. l.b.j.

we are here on earth to fart around. don't let anybody tell you any different. k.v.
2airishuman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 07:07 PM   #10
4 Rivet Member
 
Currently Looking...
Two Harbors , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 311
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2airishuman
the editors at grassroots motorsports did a 'comparison' that made the cover back in march 2003...

they pitted a honda odyssey minivan against a porsche 356 and a jaguar (series 2) xke...

on an autocross course!

the minivan lap times were equal (within 0.01 sec) to the porsche...

and they both beat the jag!

it was fun to read, and demonstrated that...

-the modern minivan handles well,
-a japanese fwd box can out race 30-40 year old english and german 'sports cars'..
-old porsches are not very fast...
-old jags look cool in the paddock...
and
-car guys get to do fun/crazy stuff....

but not many minivans entered autocross events as a result.

what's any of this have to do with towing?

the odyssey minivan was normally used to tow the editors real autocross car

so maybe it's a little bit of a surprise that a modern jag can win a handling comparison...

against a diesel truck or a bourbon...

but i'm a little disappointed the 300m couldn't take the jag...

and i'd gladly take the bathtub porsche if given the opportunity.

cheers
2air'
Ya...but where did the Duramax/Allison finish?

Tom R
__________________
TomR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 07:18 PM   #11
Rivet Master
 
Mikethefixit's Avatar
 
1977 27' Overlander
Trotwood , Ohio
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 2,153
Send a message via Yahoo to Mikethefixit
I agree with most of what 2 air has said. This in not gospel but 45 yrs OTR experence speaking.
#1 Stay away from Big Trucks. I mean way away. If U can't see that drivers mirrors ,he can't see U.
#2 Go around Major metro areas if an alter. route is available.
#3 If U have to go thru and its mutipule lanes, travel in the 2nd lane from the right ,to allow exits and entrances. No lane changing U dont gain anything.
#4 NO TAILGATING Leave U aplace to go when things come to a HALT
# 5 Dont hurry, Hurry wastes fuel and can get U hurt.Leave a little early.
2 air and I have big trucks for a reason,like someone said U can start a freight train with a sewing machine motor.But OH BOY when ya try to stop
#6 BE SAFE EVERYONE
I want to talk to U here and not READ about ya in the Papers
Roger
__________________
Mikethefixit is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 07:21 PM   #12
_
 
. , .
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,812
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomR
Ya...but where did the Duramax/Allison finish? Tom R
i couldn't tell ya, i drive a blue oval!

cheers
2air'

of course with the 19th century rigid front axle the ford is no slalom winner!

Fast On Race Day!
__________________
all of the true things that i am about to tell you are shameless lies. l.b.j.

we are here on earth to fart around. don't let anybody tell you any different. k.v.
2airishuman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 08:24 PM   #13
4 Rivet Member
 
Currently Looking...
Two Harbors , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 311
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mikethefixit
2 air and I have big trucks for a reason,like someone said U can start a freight train with a sewing machine motor.But OH BOY when ya try to stop
Roger
Hi Roger...one thing I am confused about...I thought the trailer brakes stopped the trailer...and in fact a well set brake controller should be set to come on strong enough that the trailer brakes actually helped stop the tow vehicle??

Someone stated that a well set up trailer braking system w/TV should stop the two (ie trailer plus TV) in a shorter distance than just the TV stops on its own?? (please for this ignore any potential failure of trailer brakes!). Seems like the truck needs big brakes mostly to stop the big truck? ...and just in case the trailer brakes fail when you are going down a steep mountain pass.

Do the truck brakes stop the trailer or is it the trailer brakes that not only stop the trailer but actually help the truck stop in less distance than it stops by itself???...as other have suggested?

Thanks...Tom R
__________________
TomR is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-23-2007, 08:41 PM   #14
Rivet Master<br><img src="/ugala/forums/images/5rivet.gif">
 
CanoeStream's Avatar

 
2006 25' Safari FB SE
St. Cloud , Minnesota
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 13,279
Images: 19
Blog Entries: 3
Quote:
Originally Posted by TomR
Do the truck brakes stop the trailer or is it....
In a perfect world? All towing setups will "lose it" at some point -- some earlier than others. A fly-by-wire F-16 has triple redundant systems but early experience revealed that Murphy's law led to the inevitable. A brake controller is a single layer system -- stay on top of the adjustments or not, it is never perfect. Until that point I do count on the trailer brakes to usually stop the trailer. Yes.

Go back 4-5 years and you'll find "Will Hensley's allow me to tow thru snow to the ski slope" threads. Not a good idea.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim Croce
You don't tug on Superman's cape,You don't spit into the wind,You don't pull the mask off the old Lone Ranger, And you don't mess around with Jim, da do da do...
What constitutes a reasonably stout tow situation is open to various views. Those opinions are hard to shake. I once thought a Volvo XC70 Cross Country would get me into Airstreaming just fine. Reserves are extraordinarily useful for any situation. Read 2air's scenarios for the real life experience they suggest. Given a problem, I feel my tow vehicle alone will allow me to bring my combined rig to a strong, controlled stop if I drive with a reasonable 3-dimensional awareness of driving conditions and my surroundings. I do not buy the idea that my GMC will lose it before a Dodge Intrepid, Jag or Cayenne. It's a margin of comfort thing. Experience will back up my level of comfort.
__________________

__________________
Bob

5 meter Langford Nahanni

CanoeStream is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
emergency brakes PeterH-Airstreamer Mechanics Corner - Engines, Transmission & More... 8 08-06-2012 07:02 AM
Are you a two lane or interstate type? Boondocker On The Road... 56 12-11-2009 12:17 AM
gray water handling darin Waste Systems, Tanks & Totes 2 01-08-2004 10:04 PM
Emergency parts Bill Resseau Mechanics Corner - Engines, Transmission & More... 11 04-23-2003 10:21 PM
Memory Lane--Avion, Boles-Aero, Spartan Manor Kistler Our Community 1 12-29-2002 08:02 PM


Virginia Campgrounds

Reviews provided by




Copyright 2002- Social Knowledge, LLC All Rights Reserved.

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:42 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Airstream is a registered trademark of Airstream Inc. All rights reserved. Airstream trademark used under license to Social Knowledge LLC.