Quote:
Originally Posted by Friday
Thanks... we're talking in the context of V6 Highlanders here... not freight trains.
Question: Can a Highlander V6 pull a 19 footer?
Answer: Yes.
|
Context understood^. My point was about what I felt was an inaccurate generalization about 5/6 speed transmissions top gears and towing RVs. Freight trains' diesel generation of electricity for electric motors notwithstanding ... TORQUE makes the difference in internal combustion diesel vs gas engines and gearing for towing. PERIOD
I was attracted to this thread because
we have a similar sized V-6 SUV.
Agreed, a Highlander V6 can pull a 19 footer ... 'just dislike seeing the earlier inaccurate generalization on transmissions towing RVs.
My apologies for anyone who was offended by my attempt at clarification. Heck, we can pull our 20' with our 2-door Jeep Wrangler V-6 as well - and, often do. The gas V-6 delivers great mileage, but O/D is locked out on mountain passes resulting in higher fuel consumption as well as a climbing transmission temperature; the engine needs to be kept in the torque band...regardless of horsepower. We had the same situation with the previous gas Mopar straight six, a bullet-proof transmission, a much lighter hard sided pop-up AND a transmission auxilliary cooler with an accurate temperature guage. Is that comparable info for those of you that expressed negativity on my clarification regarding top 5/6 gears as being inappropriate. A concern for us is the hitch receiver - although reinforced - being up to the job on the Wrangler frame ... TV mass vs AS mass ... very close; so, we generally reduce our travel speed accordingly.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Friday
I would suggest there aren't many 5 or 6 speed transmissions that belong in top gear (overdrive if that is how it is labelled) when towing any kind of RV... You'll find the engines tend to lug and may even get worse mileage than dropping a gear.
|