Which Brake Controller????

blrpix · 07-25-2004, 08:56 PM

I need a brake controller for my SUV...GMC Yukon...I have the tow package, so it is pre-wired...

How is the Prodogy...I was told it is the best???

Any other sugestions....

Thanks.

PWRSTRK · 07-25-2004, 09:11 PM

We bought the BrakeSmart about three weeks ago directly from the company. It's sophisticated and we are thrilled with it (towed 2500 miles over eight days) and we'd do it again in a minute.

Tom and Frank

Tin Hut · 07-25-2004, 09:19 PM

I have the Prodigy. Worked fine. Just bought a Brakesmart for new tow vehicle.

silverback · 07-25-2004, 09:20 PM

The Prodigy works great. We've used one on two Airstreams. It's one of two brake controllers (the other being the Jordan Ultima) that most forum members recommend. They each use different technology and people tend to feel strongly about them (I didn't say holy war...). Do a search on the forum and you will find many discussions and in depth analysis on this topic. One of the all time favorites. After my forum research I picked the Prodigy.
Ken

Porky Pig · 07-25-2004, 09:26 PM

I have the BrakeSmart ... more expensive than the Jordon or Prodigy ... but worth it.

**Stefrobrts** · 07-25-2004, 09:35 PM

I started with a Digitrac II, sold to me by the local trailer shop when we bought the rig. When I got a new axel and replaced the brakes we upgraded to the Prodigy because the Digitrac had caused the brakes to overheat and they had stress cracks on them. The shop felt this was because the Digitrac applied the brakes on a timer, and over however many seconds it would ramp up to full power and keep it there. Driving home with the Prodigy, it appeared to vary how much power it applied to the brakes, and then it let off after we were stopped, even though my foot was still on the pedal. So hopefully the new brakes will last longer with the new Prodigy. The old brakes were only a couple years old if that, because the PO replaced them right before I bought it. Guess I should have started out with the Prodigy.

blrpix · 07-25-2004, 09:44 PM

I am seriously considering th Prodigy or the Brakesmart now that I have been poking around reading everyone opinions...I don't care so much about the extra $ as long as I don't have to buy another one in a month!

Tin Hut...since you have both, do you have a preference?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Hut

I have the Prodigy. Worked fine. Just bought a Brakesmart for new tow vehicle.

Thanks again all...

RivetED · 07-25-2004, 09:57 PM

Is the 'Brakesmart' the one that ties into the master cyl. for it's input???

JohnG · 07-25-2004, 10:03 PM

What I like best about the Jordon is the fact that it works in conjunction with your brake pedal. The more brake you apply the more brakes the Jordon will apply.
It is very simple to hook up and use.

The brakesmart works simular, but instead of hooking to the brake pedal it hooks into the actual brake line reading the pressure you use to brake and applying thusly. This is also a good system, but a bit more complicated to hook up.

The Profigy is far above the other motion sensitive brake controllors and it is simple to hook up also.

JohnG · 07-25-2004, 10:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed & Debbie

Is the 'Brakesmart' the one that ties into the master cyl. for it's input???

That's the one.............

silverback · 07-25-2004, 10:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed & Debbie

Is the 'Brakesmart' the one that ties into the master cyl. for it's input???

It does use a pressure sensor tied into the brake lines. I've just reviewed some posts on other forums and it's highly recommended. My own preference is for electronics vs. mechanical (Jordan) or brake system surgery. That's why I originally picked the Prodigy. The BrakeSmart does sound like it's the hot item right now though.
Ken

JohnG · 07-25-2004, 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by silverback

It does use a pressure sensor tied into the brake lines. I've just reviewed some posts on other forums and it's highly recommended. My own preference is for electronics vs. mechanical (Jordan) or brake system surgery. That's why I originally picked the Prodigy. The BrakeSmart does sound like it's the hot item right now though.
Ken

The Jordon's mechanical portion is only the cable that attaches to the brake pedal. It attaches very easy to the clamp and housing porvided and that part is hooked up by tightening 2 set screws.
When the brakes are applied the cable is pulled and how much pull will determine how much the unit applies brakes to the trailer. There is also a sensitivity set on the Jordon so you can make the brakes more or less sensitive. Very simple really.
I really wouldn't want to get into brake surgery as you have put it myself, but I think the brakesmart is a good system. However, if I were to purchase one I would de3finately have it installed by a professional. Don't like the idea of something going wrong (Hate Mr. Murphy) and suddenly having no brakes.
If it's electronics that you like then the choice should be the Prodigy without question. IMHO It is far far ahead of the others of the same catagory.

RivetED · 07-25-2004, 10:24 PM

Thanks Silverback. I have a digital type with the 'time-delay-to-full-power' circuit. It was a quick fix addition when first purchased. Need something better for the same reasons as posted above.
I've seen the Brakesmart type? (not sure if there is another brand) that ties to the master cyl. & was impressed. The Prodigy has also been a serious consideration. I'll be getting a new controller before our trip to Jackson Center in Aug.; appx. 2500 mi. tround trip. I'll post which one I get and opine on it's merits &/or faults.

dbtolman · 07-25-2004, 10:38 PM

I'm using the Tekonsha Envoy. Tried to decide between it and the Prodigy... My tow vehicle is a 97 Expedition. I towed the 27' I just purchased over 500 miles, and it worked wonderfully! STICK WITH TEKONSHA!!