2-Wheel Tow Dollies

hmsteader · 10-18-2009, 08:13 PM

I'd like to know the pros & cons of the different braking systems of two wheel tow dollies. I'm led to believe that if one wanted a braking system on a tow dolly that the surge brakes are the best to have. Your comments please.

Paul Dobbin · 10-30-2009, 01:29 PM

I'm not sure I've ever see a tow dolly with brakes.
I gave up on tow dollies and went to a trailer or flat towing early in
my RVing llife. This was after two scary experiences.
#1. I was towing my 1934 Ford Tudor on a tow dolly (From Florida to NH and back). On the way back I stopped in Scranton PA and inspected my rig and found one wheel tie down stap missing! $35.00 later I was on the road again and felt real lucky I still had my favorite car.
#2 I was on I-75 in Georgia with the same car on the dolly when a trucker called me on the CB and said "You know that old car has a flat tire
on the back". It had blown one of the radial tires I put on with modern wheels just for towing and the steel belts had nearly destroyed the rear fender on my favorite car.
I bought a trailer. (was also warned by a trucker that the trailer had a flat, which damaged the trailer fender but not my 1934 Ford Phaeton!)
When traveling with our 1966 VW or our 2006 Saturn Vue we flat tow them, but keep the CB on and hope for friendly truckers.
I have used surge brakes before and found them to a good solution and less tempormental than electric brakes. But I never had them on a dolly.

Skater · 10-31-2009, 07:19 AM

I have a Stehl with electric brakes. I hate the dolly, but not because of the brakes. Master Tow also makes them with electric brakes, and I think there's at least one more brand with electric brakes whose name escapes me at the moment. So they're definitely out there. I got a good brake controller - Tekonsha Prodigy - and I haven't had any problems on that end.

I haven't tried surge brakes, but I do kinda like having control over the brakes myself. For example, one time the camper lost its brakes, and I used the dolly's brakes to help slow down. Obviously you DON'T want to do this if you can at all avoid it, but with electric you at least have the ability.

But others I've talked to who tow in general (not dollies specifically) say surge is much better. Haven't tried it myself.

Mikethefixit · 10-31-2009, 07:24 AM

There must be something to the surge brake thing. Take a look at the largest trailer rental place in the country. Every trailer has SURGE BRAKES.

Buckaroo · 10-31-2009, 08:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Dobbin

I'm not sure I've ever see a tow dolly with brakes.
I gave up on tow dollies and went to a trailer or flat towing early in
my RVing llife. This was after two scary experiences.
#1. I was towing my 1934 Ford Tudor on a tow dolly (From Florida to NH and back). On the way back I stopped in Scranton PA and inspected my rig and found one wheel tie down stap missing! $35.00 later I was on the road again and felt real lucky I still had my favorite car.
#2 I was on I-75 in Georgia with the same car on the dolly when a trucker called me on the CB and said "You know that old car has a flat tire
on the back". It had blown one of the radial tires I put on with modern wheels just for towing and the steel belts had nearly destroyed the rear fender on my favorite car.
I bought a trailer. (was also warned by a trucker that the trailer had a flat, which damaged the trailer fender but not my 1934 Ford Phaeton!)
When traveling with our 1966 VW or our 2006 Saturn Vue we flat tow them, but keep the CB on and hope for friendly truckers.
I have used surge brakes before and found them to a good solution and less tempormental than electric brakes. But I never had them on a dolly.

No offense, but I see nothing in the above post that has to do with the question posed about brakes.

Seems to me every one of your tire problems would be easily solved by the installation of tire pressure monitors on all of the tires on your RV and toads, be they cars with or without a tow dolly or a trailer in which you have a vehicle. With tire pressure monitors you would have known that your tires had lost air long before it would have been obvious to those passing you by.

I see absolutely no correlation between the question about brakes on tow dollies and the problems you had with tires not holding air.

**85MH325** · 10-31-2009, 01:38 PM

I have had three Master Tow 80THD dollies with electric brakes, and my current dolly is an 80THD with electric brakes. Surge brakes only work AFTER your rig starts to slow, and cannot help slow the towed load first. Electric brakes with a good controller (Prodigy or P3 or equivalent) is the only way to go.

Roger

**85MH325** · 10-31-2009, 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mikethefixit

There must be something to the surge brake thing. Take a look at the largest trailer rental place in the country. Every trailer has SURGE BRAKES.

Roger, that's because surge brakes require nothing installed on the tow vehicle (like a brake controller), and will suffice in all states to meet their trailer brake laws. Unfortunately, they're not particularly effective.

Roger

gunner · 10-31-2009, 02:27 PM

I towed my 1989 Cadillac on a Master Tow Dolly with Surge Brakes behind my 345 Motorhome. I did this until I got a Jeep Wrangler and tow four down. The surge brakes were a tremendous help when slowing down or coming to a stop. My boat trailer also has surge brakes with a 2,500 lbs. boat. With both the Tow Dolly and Boat Trailer there is not the pressure on the Tow Vehicle when slowing or stopping due to the Surge Brakes.

**85MH325** · 10-31-2009, 03:39 PM

Gunner, first, unless you've beefed up your chassis, a 345 is limited to 2,000 lbs towing. Your Caddie was waaay over weight for a factory tow setup per the P30 chassis specs. But don't feel bad... long before I knew what the mohos were actually rated for, I towed a Lincoln Continental with our 325 on a Master Tow 80THD, but with electric brakes.

Again, surge brakes work fine AFTER the tow vehicle brakes engage and start to slow the two vehicle. Then as the towed trailer begins to try to run over the tow vehicle and the coupler spoon rams into the hitch ball, the hydraulic surge brakes are activated. Surge brakes are better than nothing at all; but not much, IMHO.

They're adequate for light boat trailers and are used primarily because the hydraulics are a closed system that isn't as subject to water intrusion and corrosion as the electrics are. But for anything that isn't going to be regularly submerged, I just can't recommend surge brakes over electrics with a good controller.

Roger

gunner · 11-01-2009, 03:57 AM

Yes I beefed up my chassis, had to since one side of the stock hitch broke off while towing a 1,500 lb. Bass Boat on the way to our camping site, luckily it happened while towing through a small town going 25 MPH. My experience has been that the surge brakes helped tremendously during the braking process. The only time they are of hindrence is when backing the trailer etc. up a hill, then you have to lock out the surge brakes.

klattu · 11-01-2009, 05:00 AM

I like using a dolly...
quick to load and off load...
easy to fimd a spot to store at campsite...
Most cars today are FWD, so no drive shaft to worry about.

To move up from a dolly would be to flat tow.

GlenCoombe · 11-01-2009, 05:24 AM

Klattu, nice caddy sir. But aren't you concerned about road debris when using a dolly? I sure wouldn't want to put my 87 Allante on a dolly for that reason.

Do you have a rock guard on either the dolly or the motorhome?

Gunner, what flavor Cadillac is yours?

When it comes time to paint the topsides on the AS I'm going to use the same paint as was used to repaint the caddy so they match.

Mine will go on the trailer.

gunner · 11-01-2009, 06:40 AM

Mine was a 1989 Cadillac Deville, 2 Door, Gold Edition. I have since sold it and purchased a 2000 Corvette convertible. I also purchased a Wrangler Jeep to tow behind the Motorhome.

GlenCoombe · 11-02-2009, 05:39 PM

Gunner, assuming you went from a hard top to the 'vert vet you've at least got the wind in your hair some of the time.

There's nothing like driving your caddy topless.